[Build 136] Build 136 RC1 : Custrom Project : Optimizer Task : 4 Points 3D instead of one 3D Point

in Custrom Project : Optimizer Task :



1/     We have  4 Points 3D instead of one Point 3D on each position of the grid 


2/     The 3D surface is on inaccurate position , it should be higher


3 /     the Drop menu is not in alphabetic order 


please look the capture attached 


please find attached the strategy and the optimizer config 





Attachments
image-0.png
(234.61 KiB)
image-1.undefined
(102.82 KiB)
Optimize strategies 4 results.cfx
(45.72 KiB)
  • Votes +3
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Bug
  • Status Fixed
  • Priority Normal

History

E
#1

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 20:28

Task created

E
#2

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 20:28
Voted for this task.
E
#3

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 20:41

Attachment Bug 3D.rar added

Bug 3D.rar
(7.47 MiB)
here are some files of  the optimization



E
#4

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 20:54

Description changed:

in Custrom Project : Optimizer Task :


1/     I have  4 Points 3D results instead of one on each position of the grid 


2/     The 3D surface is on inaccurate position , it should be higher



please look the capture attached 


please find attached the strategy and the optimizer config 





Attachment image-0.png added

image-0.png
(172.68 KiB)
E
#5

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 20:55

Description changed:

in Custrom Project : Optimizer Task :



1/     I have  4 Points 3D results instead of one Points 3D on each position of the grid 



2/     The 3D surface is on inaccurate position , it should be higher



please look the capture attached 


please find attached the strategy and the optimizer config 





E
#6

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 20:59

Description changed:

in Custrom Project : Optimizer Task :



1/     We have  4 Points 3D results instead of one Points 3D on each position of the grid 


2/     The 3D surface is on inaccurate position , it should be higher


3 /     the Drop menu is not in alphabetic order 

It is  difficult  to select

please look the capture attached 


please find attached the strategy and the optimizer config 





Attachment image-0.png added

image-0.png
(197.45 KiB)
E
#7

Emmanuel

02.12.2022 21:01

Description changed:

in Custrom Project : Optimizer Task :



1/     We have  4 Points 3D results instead of one Points 3D on each position of the grid 


2/     The 3D surface is on inaccurate position , it should be higher


3 /     the Drop menu is not in alphabetic order 


please look the capture attached 


please find attached the strategy and the optimizer config 





Fs
#8

Fortunate

02.12.2022 22:21
Voted for this task.
E
#9

Emmanuel

03.12.2022 03:17

Subject changed from Build 136 RC1 : Custrom Project : Optimizer Task : 4 3D results instead of one to Build 136 RC1 : Custrom Project : Optimizer Task : 4 Points 3D instead of one 3D Points

E
#10

Emmanuel

03.12.2022 03:18

Subject changed from Build 136 RC1 : Custrom Project : Optimizer Task : 4 Points 3D instead of one 3D Points to Build 136 RC1 : Custrom Project : Optimizer Task : 4 Points 3D instead of one 3D Point

Description changed:

in Custrom Project : Optimizer Task :



1/     We have  4 Points 3D instead of one Point 3D on each position of the grid 


2/     The 3D surface is on inaccurate position , it should be higher


3 /     the Drop menu is not in alphabetic order 


please look the capture attached 


please find attached the strategy and the optimizer config 





E
#11

Emmanuel

12.12.2022 14:57
we need this to be fix in Build 136, it can not wait B137 to fix it

the view is not working correctly at all

TT
#12

Tamas

12.12.2022 16:26
Hello Emmanuel :)

1/     We have  4 Points 3D instead of one Point 3D on each position of the grid 

This is correct, because it is optimized by more than 3 parameters, so for one combination of x,y there can be more Z results


other points are just UI problems


136 final should be out tomorrow.

E
#13

Emmanuel

12.12.2022 17:20
what do represent the other Z results ? which one is the net profit ?
TT
#14

Tamas

12.12.2022 18:34

Optimized params are on horizontal axis. the performance metric (NetProfit) is on vertical axis.


Let's assume that the strategy has only 3 params Period1, Period2, Period3

Period1=5;Period2=10;Period3=100; => NetProfit=100

Period1=5;Period2=10;Period3=200; => NetProfit=200

Period1=5;Period2=10;Period3=300; => NetProfit=-500

Period1=5;Period2=10;Period3=400; => NetProfit=-900

...


now we want to display 3D chart for x=Period1/ y=Period2

for combination 5/10 there are multiple NetProfit results. 


3D surface chart is displaying only the best/worst Z value (based on the stat type Maximize/Minimize).

3D point chart is displaying the best and also the worst Z value + some others (I think max 5 dots for one combination)


Is it clear now ? 


E
#15

Emmanuel

13.12.2022 13:13
Thank you Tamas for your reply


I understand your explanation but I don't see how we can use this 4 Points 3D view to select the best parameters


4 points 3D is making things complicated and not very clear to select the best parameters


Is it possible to keep this   4 Points 3D view as an Option ?


And keep one point 3D view as regular view ?


E
#16

Emmanuel

18.12.2022 13:49
We can not use the optimizer with this 4 points 3D view


And we can not wait B137 , next year without optimizer


please, put it back like it was with 1 point 3D on Build 136

TT
#17

Tamas

18.12.2022 17:36

We can ask Marc to add the requested feature to 136 final but why 3d point chart is so important fo you? 


You can switch the chart to 3d surface or 2d heat map

E
#18

Emmanuel

18.12.2022 21:21
The 3D point view should work correctly with one 3D point on each position like before. 


(As you can see on the chart, the actual chart is not clear with 4  points on each position) 


the 3D surface do not work correctly as well, the surface 3D is not at the correct position.  



b
#19

bentra

19.12.2022 02:39
Voted for this task.
TT
#20

Tamas

21.12.2022 09:54

Status changed from New to Fixed

We have added new chart view "3D point" which shows only one point (best / worst result based on stat type,  same as surface chart)


Fixed in 136 final, already downloadable from our site


Votes: +3

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please