<- Back to Tasks

100% different strategies, but the results match 100%

3 completely different strategies are presented with different used indicators and their values, but the results match all 3 100%, isn't that strange?

Attachments

Strategy 230114.sqx

(61.31 KiB)

Screenshot_1.png

(134.81 KiB)

Screenshot_2-2.png

(43.02 KiB)

Strategy 410180.sqx

(61.41 KiB)

Screenshot_3.png

(135.85 KiB)

Strategy 126103.sqx

(61.41 KiB)

Screenshot_3-2.png

(39.59 KiB)

Screenshot_2.png

(134.24 KiB)

Screenshot_1-2.png

(37.93 KiB)

Votes +1
Project StrategyQuant X
Type Bug
Status Fixed
Priority Normal

History

Partizanas

15.12.2022 16:44

Task created

bentra

15.12.2022 16:55

Not strange. Completely different looking logic conditions can be effectively always true or always false. Not 100% different because Price level, SL and TP are all the same in all your strategies so, no, not strange.

Emmanuel

17.12.2022 13:18

Voted for this task.

Lee Guan Chuan

09.02.2023 06:47

Status changed from New to Fixed

Hi,

I have checked the strategies. It is correct, but I could be wrong on this too. This is how I check.

I manually combine the signal into 1 strategy and execute it, which still gives the same results. This means the signal gives the same signal at the same times.
I see that all signals are using <> (not equal); most of the time, the indicator values cannot be similar, which may lead to the signal happening for these 3 strategies.
I tried to add some other rules, and it successfully changed how the strategy behaves
I have checked the code, and it is correct.

Do let me know if you find any suspicious issues. I'll mark this as fixed right now.

Thank you.

Votes: +1