Slippage calculating is not correct when MMmethod is applied to a strategy

      1. As you can see,   slippage is obviously calculated based on $ per trade in SQX. But when the strategy is retested with MM method, in most cases, it is not reasonable to spend the same slippage on each trade.
      2. There is ambiguity about“pips $ per trade" in Test parameters of data setting.
      3. default slippage *pips in Datamanager is wrong, in fact it is  calulated based on dollar per trade
      4. Sometimes, When batch testing is required on different commodities, silppage setting "pips per contract" is more universal.
       To sum up, it is recommended to support slippage setting option (per trade or per contract, pips per contract or dollar per contract)like Multicharts.   Include in defaut slippage setting of Datamanger and slippage setting of Builder,Retester,Optimizer

Attachments
slippage setting.jpg
(85.92 KiB)
slippage in trade list.jpg
(422.53 KiB)
default silppage in Datamanager.jpg
(55.76 KiB)
slippage setting in Multicharts.jpg
(60.43 KiB)
  • Votes +2
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Bug
  • Status New
  • Priority Normal

History

b
#1

binhsir

05.03.2023 04:59

Task created

b
#2

binhsir

05.03.2023 05:03

Description changed:

      1. As you can see,   slippage is obviously calculated based on $ per trade in SQX. But when the strategy is retested with MM method, in most cases, it is not reasonable to spend the same slippage on each trade.
      2. There is ambiguity about“pips $ per trade" in Test parameters of data setting.
      3. default slippage *pips in Datamanager is wrong, in fact it is  calulated based on dollar per trade

      4. Sometimes, When batch testing is required on different commodities, silppage setting "pips per contract" is more universal.
       To sum up, it is recommended to support slippage setting option (per trade or per contract, pips per contract or dollar per contract)like Multicharts.   Include in defaut slippage setting of Datamanger and slippage setting of Builder,Retester,Optimizer

b
#3

binhsir

09.03.2023 10:21
Voted for this task.
E
#4

Emmanuel

13.04.2023 23:36
Voted for this task.

Votes: +2

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please