[Build 128] Portfolio - optionally merge also source codes of strategies in portfolio

add option to merge source codes of all strategies into one strategy when merging them into portfolio.
Attachments
No attachments
  • Votes +22
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Feature
  • Status Fixed
  • Priority Low

History

MF
#1

Mark Fric

04.06.2018 08:05

Task created

m
#2

mabi

27.06.2018 04:47
Dont forgett this , awesome feature. Just merge 100 strategies as one and throw them on a MT4 account for incubation would be great and incredible time saving plus give some future possebilities of hughe demotraded portfolios allowing for EQ control by magic number for copying for real trades only strategies with top current performance maybe.
l
#3

Blade Runner

29.06.2018 13:18
Sometime ago I've sent Jan and Zdenek a document with suggestions of product improvement focused in SQ and QA (I wasn't aware of this tool by then yet :) ). I believe i has been delivered to you Marc. 


If I had to select just one suggestion from the document I sent SQ team, this would be the one. I detail in that document why is this feature so powerful and important.


I understand this is marked with Low priority because I foresee to be a real big jump in the MQL4 code generation from where SQ is standing now, but please read that section of that document to understand how important and powerful (also for SQ team) to implement this change. Thanks!

MF
#4

Mark Fric

13.07.2018 10:47
if you could attach the document also here it would be good, so that it won't be lost.

I think I read it, but it was long time ago, I don't remember it much.
m
#5

mabi

06.08.2018 12:37
For sure this time ?
MF
#6

Mark Fric

07.08.2018 07:15
I'm not sure we'll make it into Build 108, it has low priority and we have more impoortant tasks to finish.
m
#7

mabi

08.08.2018 03:46
Read on a forum were this is in use that one guy was running 300 strategies this way with hardly no load on one MT4 with 128 trades working.  However there need to be possibility to identify which strategy is doing what in the portfolio in order to be able to identify and extract the good ones after a couple of years on incubation. The VPS cost will be significantly lower. Today I run about 40 MT4 using 4 VPS and still have issues with MT4 stalling continuously . I guess I could run all on 1 MT4 or in worst case 2. and just one dirt cheap VPS.  :)
h
#8

hankeys

08.08.2018 06:57
this will be hell of a coding, but its not impossible...


to set more strategies in one - set everywhere symbol, TF, lotsize, riskmoney, magicnumber, etc. will be very error open


and after some time to find one strategy which i want to stop or when i want to add another strategy to portfolio...this will be the hard path - set everything from scratch, or make another EA?


i could imagine that with the appropriate syntax of the strategie, where the code could automatically set the market and TF, with the unified magicnumber syntax, where will be everything put to the code automatically, this could be very usefull


but for now, i am afraid, that this is not the way, we want to go...there are still more problematic bugs

m
#9

mabi

08.08.2018 07:28
Seems they portfolio them by time frame and instrument. Makes it simpler I suppose.
IH
#10

clonex / Ivan Hudec

09.08.2018 13:31
agree with hankeys arguing. 
m
#11

mabi

09.08.2018 23:26
Me to kind of, But most important is Live traded strategies compared with backtest and this would sure make that comparison easier and faster to find codes that do not work at all live but seems to work in back tester. I mean we had a user that found earlier this year that MT4 and SQ3 calculated the bars since entry differently. I do not know if that has been fixed now for SQ4. Probably not since some user posted strategies that  open and close immediately in MT4
o
#12

Enric

08.09.2018 10:56
Voted for this task.
o
#13

Enric

08.09.2018 11:01
I missed this discussion. It's too bad to see this feature postponed 'sine die'. Hopefully SQX will be 'robust' enough as to be able to add this practical option, I'm not happy to plan to install one MT4 terminal after another and pay extra money to VPS
h
#14

hankeys

09.09.2018 09:51
there are still major bugs...its not wise to do any job in this task for now
o
#15

Enric

09.09.2018 10:48
Of course my friend first is first, not wise to add ANY new feature until it's clean of bugs. But these feature in my opinion should be on the top
Rr
#16

Partizanas

04.10.2018 19:25
Voted for this task.
k
#17

Karish

08.10.2018 21:53
Voted for this task.
m
#18

mabi

09.10.2018 00:00
Voted for this task.
KW
#19

Sean

09.10.2018 01:25
Voted for this task.
FB
#20

lumbrjack

09.10.2018 03:53
Voted for this task.
l
#21

ludvick

09.10.2018 14:35
Voted for this task.
IH
#22

clonex / Ivan Hudec

09.10.2018 15:58
Voted for this task.
n
#23

nitroz

15.10.2018 14:54
Voted for this task.
KL
#24

kainc301

27.11.2018 15:20
Voted for this task.
KL
#25

kainc301

11.12.2018 20:35
It would be convenient if this feature could allow for strategies on multiple markets to be combined so that there wouldn't be a need to load ea's on individual markets in mt4. Seems like a hell of a coding job but I would imagine it would be beyond useful for portfolios to consist of one EA that wouldn't require users to load up multiple markets each with specific time frames and have that all processed in the background with the right trade management. This would make deploying completed projects considerably more seamless.  
FM
#26

Aimak_Rokalno

11.12.2018 22:45
Voted for this task.
a
#27

Ash24FX

16.12.2018 18:53
Voted for this task.
DV
#28

TheLibertarianTrader

21.12.2018 22:47
Voted for this task.
Tt
#29

tactevo

06.01.2019 01:59
Voted for this task.
c
#30

VaderTrader

25.02.2019 21:26
Voted for this task.
e
#31

extpan

29.03.2019 15:34
Voted for this task.
e
#32

extpan

29.03.2019 15:35
Any news for this feature? Or any other options how to combine more EA as mt4 have limit of 99EA


Thanks

GS
#33

glenn

04.05.2019 13:58
Voted for this task.
AM
#34

AndrEAs

11.12.2019 12:42
Voted for this task.
AM
#35

AndrEAs

11.12.2019 12:49
For my workflow this is the most important task.  t's been a year and a half, I hope you don't forget it, please
NH
#36

phl3x0r

12.02.2020 08:45
Voted for this task.
MF
#37

Mark Fric

16.02.2020 13:52

Status changed from New to Archived

AG
#38

Tukirito

16.02.2020 20:32
Voted for this task.
MF
#39

Mark Fric

13.05.2020 13:22

Status changed from Archived to Fixed

done in B 128
h
#40

hankeys

13.05.2020 14:19
fixed, really? does anyone tested it how it "works"?
MF
#41

Mark Fric

13.05.2020 15:33
yes, we tested it. Is there some problem with this functionality?


w
#42

wiraputu

06.12.2022 07:06
Voted for this task.

Votes: +22

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please