Algowizard in 116 has always same problem that i signed on 115

m

#1

DOMENICO

21.12.2018 23:17

Task created

m

#2

DOMENICO

22.12.2018 13:18

Attachment Algo1.sqx added

Attachment Algo1FW.sqx added

After more deep check I found these bugs

in Simple Wizard (Algo1 file) Rule OR WHEN does not work ever generating only one trade always opened.

In Full Wizard (Algo1FW file) i found that at Long Exit and Short Exit there was a wrong set about "IF then" direction. It was always long. So i have set it at any. Now it closes trade but it not respect the rules that i ordered him. Retesting the sqx in Retester you can verify on results, in the tab Trades on chart, that trades do not follow the exit rule OR WHEN.

m

#3

DOMENICO

22.12.2018 13:18

After more deep check I found these bugs

in Simple Wizard (Algo1 file) Rule OR WHEN does not work ever generating only one trade always opened.

In Full Wizard (Algo1FW file) i found that at Long Exit and Short Exit there was a wrong set about "IF then" direction. It was always long. So i have set it at any. Now it closes trade but it not respect the rules that i ordered him. Retesting the sqx in Retester you can verify on results, in the tab Trades on chart, that trades do not follow the exit rule OR WHEN.

g

#4

geektrader

23.12.2018 22:53

You should just go to the old bug report that you´ve already submitted and add a new reply there saying that it isn´t fixed yet. Opening double and triple bug-posts about the same bug just creates more confusion and lowers the chance that your bug gets fixed.

m

#5

DOMENICO

23.12.2018 23:49

I would like to do but there are not tasks in Algowizard Roadmap. This was the title.

[AlgoWizard - Bug #algw_0135] (New) Rule exit does not work

m

#6

DOMENICO

04.01.2019 15:47

Attachment MT4.png added

Attachment is not expert.png added

Attachment QQE_1.ex4 added

Attachment QQE_1.ex5 added

Attachment QQE_1.mq4 added

Attachment QQE_1.mq5 added

Attachment Algo3FW.sqx added

I compiled this strategy that does not respect rule exit OR WHEN to check on demo account if it respect the entry rules. It on MT5 works on MT4 not. I hold last version about MT4 20 December 2018. It gives me always same error QQE_1 is not an expert and I dont understand the reason.

m

#7

DOMENICO

05.01.2019 11:55

I found the matter about compiling MT4. Before I tried to compile it loading from SQ folder and it did not work. Then i tried loading file from the MT4 folder that is in editor on the left side and it strangely worked. Now I need to resolve only the Exit rule "OR WHEN" on first strategy in this post.

TB

#8

Tomas Brynda

10.01.2019 15:52

Attachment trades.png added

Attachment Algo1 - modified.sqx added

You are right, there is a bug in Close position action direction - I created a separate task for it -> https://sq.projectpanel.com/tasks/algw_0163

I tried to modify the rules in full wizard and set the short exit rule's Close position direction to Short. Then after retest I think the strategy behaves as expected - see the screenshot attached.

I also attached the modified strategy so you can take a look at the trades yourself.

Is there any other problem with this strategy?

m

#9

DOMENICO

10.01.2019 17:19

I will check it, thx.

m

#10

DOMENICO

10.01.2019 20:29

It seems ok, but had i make errors?

TB

#11

Tomas Brynda

11.01.2019 08:22

Status changed from New to Fixed

The Long direction in both Close position actions created by using Or when in simple Wizard was our internal bug. But you wrote that when you modified the strategy in full wizard, you set the direction to Any.

This would cause unexpected position closing, because the live position would close when any of the two exit signals were evaluated as true.

Algowizard in 116 has always same problem that i signed on 115

History

DOMENICO

DOMENICO

DOMENICO

geektrader

DOMENICO

DOMENICO

DOMENICO

Tomas Brynda

DOMENICO

DOMENICO

Tomas Brynda