Official Git based repository for SQX components

Hello,

What am I missing is an official  git based repository with SQX "Extend" directory components?  Benefits are clear and no need to explain from community and business perspective.

Any chance?

BR Enyx



Attachments
No attachments
  • Votes 0
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Feature
  • Status Refused
  • Priority Normal

History

DB
#1

Enyx

19.04.2020 11:37

Task created

h
#2

hankeys

19.04.2020 17:56
DB
#3

Enyx

19.04.2020 23:10

Thank you. My request is more like having standard SQX templates and indicators stored in a version repository so we can easily spot the differences between builds.

MF
#4

Mark Fric

20.04.2020 08:40

Status changed from New to Refused

I understand your point, but it doesn't seem necessary to me. I doubt there will be more than a few persons who would look at it.


Generation of cde is also partly dependent on other internal libraries and changes, so it is not always possible to use code from one version in another.


If you are interested in changes between versions yoiu can make a simple diff by yourself.

h
#5

hankeys

20.04.2020 10:44
there are not so many differences in the SQX building blocks itselff


for now only "is uptrend" "is downtrend" is added to B126

DB
#6

Enyx

20.04.2020 11:13

Thank you for your reply.


I do already have it version controlled. That's not the point.


Those few people you mentioned care, are willing to contribute and not just consuming the product as such. Let's imagine there is a blocking/stability bug (and it's not an exception). It will be much easier to simply identify the problem, submit a PR to the development team which will review and potentially get it's path in the next release.  It's a win-win situation. I need a stable product which I can trust.


SQX has wonderful extensibility features (which won me) but it i feel very painful to get any kind of support from company itself. For the record, I have requested such support in the past it has been directly refused. I do not understand the business model. The usual feedback i get from my peer is that SQX is a wonderful product (I confirm) but it's reliability and consistency is lacking behind (I confirm that too). Currently using old SQX122 as SQX126 is broken for my needs.


Don't kill the community.


Enyx

MF
#7

Mark Fric

20.04.2020 12:35
we want to support the community, not kill it :)


If you were refused before maybe it was some misunderstanding, I don't know what exactly you asked for. I cannot find an email from your address.


But I still don't understand what you are requesting in this task. Code generaton is only a very small part of the whole SQ code, so even if it were versioned in Git you'd be not able to "fix" any more serious bug in SQ.

And we definitely don't want to open our full source code for public access.

DB
#8

Enyx

20.04.2020 13:44

Thank you for your private message. I've provided you the evidence. Let me get back to initial request.


I do fully agree with you that bugs withing internal SQX libraries cannot be fixed by end user. And I do fully respect company's intellectual property.


On the other side "user" components within extend directory are available with full source code. I am requesting for official repository on this part only like other products do. Anyway this code is indeed available by just downloading trial or zip file of product.


Hope that makes sense.


Votes: 0

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please