b129dev2 - custom blocks problems

OK, setting the params in the custom blocks was removed from custom blocks itself and there is only info that the settings should be done in the builder settings



this is not what i like, because custom blocks itself has some conditions and so the optimal params we want - why user need to set the conditions in one place and params in another? doesnt make sense, imagine that i could have different setfiles for builders and in everyone i need to set my params for every custom block everytime - the params need to be in the custom block, there is no other way


... so i set now only the default value of params, but if i go to builder to the custom block, where is the defatult values i set in the custom block? no...there are totally different default values with some ranges i didnt set...i set fixed default value, because i could set nothing else...so this is not working properly and default values are not accepted from custom blocks


second - so for now i have minimum as 10, maximum 30, step 2 for the range param - if i try to change i cant, if i click minus, the values stays the same, but after click save they are changed


and the param "bars" has minimum 2, cant set 1


so the changing of params doesnt work at all

Attachments
param.jpg
(49.48 KiB)
param2.jpg
(133.47 KiB)
  • Votes +1
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Bug
  • Status Fixed
  • Priority Normal

History

h
#1

hankeys

16.06.2020 10:04

Task created

h
#2

hankeys

16.06.2020 10:04
Voted for this task.
h
#3

hankeys

16.06.2020 10:05

Description changed:

OK, setting the params in the custom blocks was removed from custom blocks itself and there is only info that the settings should be done in the builder settings



this is not what i like, because custom blocks itself has some conditions and so the optimal params we want - why user need to set the conditions in one place and params in another? doesnt make sense, imagine that i could have different setfiles for builders and in everyone i need to set my params for every custom block everytime - the params need to be in the custom block, there is no other way


... so i set now only the default value of params, but if i go to builder to the custom block, where is the defatult values i set in the custom block? no...there are totally different default values with some ranges i didnt set...i set fixed default value, because i could set nothing else...so this is not working properly and default values are not accepted from custom blocks


second - so for now i have minimum as 10, maximum 30, step 2 for the range param - if i try to change i cant, if i click minus, the values stays the same, but after click save they are changed


and the param "bars" has minimum 2, cant set 1


so the changing of params doesnt work at all

TB
#4

Tomas Brynda

18.06.2020 14:06

Status changed from New to Fixed

Hi Hankeys,

I have fixed the issue concerning parameters having limited value range in Building blocks settings.


We have decided to removed the min/max/step settings from custom blocks screen, so the only place where the values ranges are set is Building blocks settings.


Best regards,

Tomas

h
#5

hankeys

18.06.2020 14:20
this decision is not good - because why we have some custom blocks - because behind them is some idea and if i want to use some params its normal by my opinion to set them right to a custom block itself, because it has the idea


imagine that you will have 4 building settings for each pair and TF and for every one (trading 5 markets will be 90 combinations) and in every this buidling tasks i will need to set my custom blocks manually


behind CUSTOM BLOCKS lies IDEA and if the idea has the parameters it should be set, where the idea is - because the params making the idea


please reconsider this


its the same like templates - if i have idea for the template i can set the params too in the template itself

MF
#6

Mark Fric

18.06.2020 15:02
ok, after some discussion we'll return back setting of min, max, value parameters in custom blocks.


If they will be all set to 0 then it wil use settings from Building blocksĀ  config.

h
#7

hankeys

18.06.2020 20:18
nice one

Votes: +1

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please