entry symmetry doesnt work

h

#1

hankeys

12.11.2020 22:36

Task created

h

#2

hankeys

12.11.2020 22:43

no symmetry on fractals

Open Long order at FractalDown(Main chart,3)[2] Stop;

Open Short order at FractalDown(Main chart,3)[2] Stop;

JH

#3

Jabezz

13.11.2020 07:40

Voted for this task.

b

#4

gin

13.11.2020 10:57

Voted for this task.

h

#5

hankeys

13.11.2020 23:01

another one - i have not selected building block "CCI is raising/falling" i am still getting strats with them

LongEntrySignal = (CCI(Main chart,24) is falling 6 consecutive bars);

ShortEntrySignal = (CCI(Main chart,24) is rising 6 consecutive bars)

o

#6

Enric

15.11.2020 10:57

Voted for this task.

MF

#7

Mark Fric

16.11.2020 09:52

Status changed from New to Waiting for information

I fixed Fractal negation.

I cannot reproduce the other two issues mentioned - in my tests entry symmetry is always there and CCI is not used if not selected.

Can you attach your build config that produces this?

MF

#8

Mark Fric

16.11.2020 11:04

Status changed from Waiting for information to In progress

ok, I was able to reproduce it, entry symmetry sometimes does't work, I'll look at it.

MF

#9

Mark Fric

24.11.2020 10:05

Status changed from In progress to Fixed

fixed, the problem was that there were some checks missing for crossover

h

#10

hankeys

26.11.2020 20:01

another one from dev2

LongEntrySignal = Vortex(Main chart, 24)[2] changes trend UP;

ShortEntrySignal = Vortex(Main chart, 24)[2] changes trend UP;

MF

#11

Mark Fric

27.11.2020 11:08

Status changed from Fixed to Waiting for information

I checked this one the mistake was in this indicator setting, not in the engine. Did you find any other examples of wrong symmetry?

h

#12

hankeys

27.11.2020 11:13

nope

h

#13

hankeys

27.11.2020 18:27

Attachment entry.jpg added

entry.jpg

(140.90 KiB)

remaining is that even i havent choose CCI is falling/raising i am still getting strats with these entries

LongEntrySignal = (CCI(Main chart,48) is falling 6 consecutive bars);

ShortEntrySignal = (CCI(Main chart,48) is rising 6 consecutive bars)

W

#14

WJPII

28.11.2020 01:12

Voted for this task.

b

#15

bentra

28.11.2020 02:18

Voted for this task.

h

#16

hankeys

28.11.2020 22:08

another one

LongEntrySignal = ((HullMovingAverage(Main chart,120, PRICE_HIGH)[3] changes direction upwards)

and CustomBlock:Not Monday Not Friday(){(((Bar Day of Week = Tuesday)

or (Bar Day of Week = Wednesday))

or (Bar Day of Week = Thursday))});

ShortEntrySignal = (CustomBlock:Not Monday Not Friday(){(((Bar Day of Week = Tuesday)

or (Bar Day of Week = Wednesday))

or (Bar Day of Week = Thursday))}

and CustomBlock:CCI Divergence 2(12, 45){((CCI(Main chart,12, PRICE_CLOSE)[1] < CCI(Main chart,12, PRICE_CLOSE)[45])

and (Close(Main chart)[1] > Close(Main chart)[45]))});

h

#17

hankeys

28.11.2020 22:11

it seems, that symmetry is a bigger problem with new B130

LongEntrySignal = ((BearsPower(Main chart,13) crosses 0 downwards)

and (ATR(Main chart,20)[2] is falling));

ShortEntrySignal = ((BullsPower(Main chart,20) < 0)

and (ATR(Main chart,50)[2] is falling));

h

#18

hankeys

28.11.2020 22:25

and my finding is that its related to genetics building, because random is OK

b

#19

bentra

28.11.2020 22:50

Attachment SQ4StrategyTemplateExample.sq4 added

SQ4StrategyTemplateExample.sq4

(2.78 KiB)

Me too with gen builder 130dev2. I think b129 was fine with the same template. I'm using a template which should be symmetric. Like hankeys says, probably the crossover process doesn't maintain the symmetry.

//--------------------------------------------------------------------
// Trading rule: Trading signals (On Bar Open)
//--------------------------------------------------------------------                   
LongEntrySignal = ((ADX(Main chart,49) < 40)
   and (Momentum(Subchart1, D1,40, PRICE_CLOSE)[2] is rising));

ShortEntrySignal = ((ADX(Main chart,40) < 30)
   and (Stochastic(Subchart1, D1,98, 185, 153).Fast%K[3] < Stochastic(Subchart1, D1,98, 185, 153).Slow%D[3]));

LongExitSignal = (Close below BollingerBands(Main chart,20, 2, PRICE_CLOSE).LowerBand
   and (ADX(Main chart,14) < 50));

ShortExitSignal = ((Stochastic(Main chart,59, 171, 125).Slow%D[1] changes direction upwards)
   and (QQE(Subchart1, D1,46, 2, 3.22).Value1[1] > QQE.Value2));

h

#20

hankeys

29.11.2020 09:10

yes its a problem and it seems its because the changes in the genetic algorithms i read about

GA

#21

GaryAitcheson

30.11.2020 16:47

Voted for this task.

t

#22

tnickel

01.12.2020 00:05

Voted for this task.

t

#23

tnickel

01.12.2020 00:06

Attachment not symetric1.png added

Attachment not symetric2.png added

Attachment Q63 GBPUSD H1H4L15_00000.cfx added

Q63 GBPUSD H1H4L15_00000.cfx

(148.44 KiB)

not symetric1.png

(93.21 KiB)

not symetric2.png

(55.31 KiB)

I have the same problem. I have defined some custom buildingblocks.

I use 4.130 rc2

MF

#24

Mark Fric

01.12.2020 13:48

Status changed from Waiting for information to In progress

# 14

condiion: (CCI(Main chart,48) is falling 6 consecutive bars) is Woodies Trend Up/Down

It looks like the problem happens when you use custom blocks or templates, I'll check it

h

#25

hankeys

01.12.2020 13:51

but this one is not with custom blocks, so its something general

LongEntrySignal = ((BearsPower(Main chart,13) crosses 0 downwards)

and (ATR(Main chart,20)[2] is falling));

ShortEntrySignal = ((BullsPower(Main chart,20) < 0)

and (ATR(Main chart,50)[2] is falling));

MF

#26

Mark Fric

02.12.2020 13:05

Status changed from In progress to Fixed

I found the issue, it should now work correctly in all cases.

e

#27

eastpeace

12.12.2020 10:25

Voted for this task.

entry symmetry doesnt work

History

hankeys

hankeys

Jabezz

gin

hankeys

Enric

Mark Fric

Mark Fric

Mark Fric

hankeys

Mark Fric

hankeys

hankeys

WJPII

bentra

hankeys

hankeys

hankeys

bentra

hankeys

GaryAitcheson

tnickel

tnickel

Mark Fric

hankeys

Mark Fric

eastpeace