Duplicated, conditions in the signal

sq x version: b133

backtest: multicharts


I found that in some strategies, the conditions in the signals are completely duplicated. That is not at all necessary and wastes a lot of resources.



There is another strange thing. The logic of the signals in the generated trend strategies generally doesn't quite match common sense. For example, buy when rsi is falling and  short when rsi is rising.  Buy when close below supertrend, and short when close above supertrend.


I'm not quite sure if the Multicharts backtest engine is working properly. 


Attachments
Build.cfx
(34.92 KiB)
Strategy 318141.sqx
(35.17 KiB)
  • Votes +1
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Bug
  • Status New
  • Priority Normal

History

e
#1

eastpeace

09.07.2021 13:21

Task created

e
#2

eastpeace

09.07.2021 13:28

Attachment Screenshot 2021-07-09 192618.png added

Attachment Screenshot 2021-07-09 192719.png added

Attachment Screenshot 2021-07-09 192738.png added

Screenshot 2021-07-09 192738.png
(30.82 KiB)
Screenshot 2021-07-09 192719.png
(45.72 KiB)
Screenshot 2021-07-09 192618.png
(32.17 KiB)
h
#3

hankeys

12.07.2021 07:39
what is the common sense in trading in general? what works in forex has no sense at all :)


SQX is not a human, only machine...


and why the conditions cant be duplicated... for example if you choose only few building blocks...


i have talked here many times ago about something called simplifier (which will go through the used building blocks in the strategy and keep only those which are making some job in the strategy - for example remove redundant building blocks) of strats and this very usefull tool is not implemented yet and i dong know why, because new features (where i have doubts of their benefits) are added, but why?

e
#4

eastpeace

12.07.2021 08:46
According to traditional technical analysis, bullish conditions as long signal, bearish conditions as short signal, that is good. 


But I also accept the point of  machine. It's just about the statistics good or not, not the common sense.  It's just that there were not so obvious and so many opposite conditions in previous versions.


But completely duplicate conditions appear in the signal, I think it's still a bug. I chose not quite a few Blocks.

E
#5

Emmanuel

14.11.2022 20:18
Voted for this task.

Votes: +1

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please