Trades on Chart, always shows ATR in list of indicators, even if not used in strategy

Trades on Chart, always shows ATR in list of indicators, even if not used in strategy
Attachments
Screenshot 2022-07-17 144929.png
(114.58 KiB)
  • Votes +1
  • Project StrategyQuant X
  • Type Bug
  • Status Fixed
  • Priority Normal

History

AA
#1

Alex

17.07.2022 13:50

Task created

E
#2

Emmanuel

06.08.2022 15:36
Voted for this task.
TT
#3

Tamas

31.08.2022 14:14

Status changed from New to Refused

It is not a bug. ATR is predefined in the list.
AA
#4

Alex

03.09.2022 06:11
Dear StrategyQuant Team,
You can check it with any strategy that does not contain ATR.
Make one, then check indicators under trades on the chart.
Always ATR is shown.
Please recheck.
AA
#5

Alex

08.09.2022 06:55

Why you have refused this task?

When some one had not used ATR, why he should see it?


TT
#6

Tamas

08.09.2022 08:33

Type changed from Bug to Feature

Attachment image-0.png added

image-0.png
(216.87 KiB)
Because it is not a bug. ATR is displayed also on Data tab. 

Why do you think this is a bug ? :)

AA
#7

Alex

08.09.2022 09:48

Showing ATR on data tab makes sense, and we can choose OOS according to that.

But when we see tradings on chart, we look for how our strategy works with our indicators and conditions.

So it does not make sense to have ATR. And any time we want to check, we should turn off ATR manually.

I think it is good if we delete it in the shown list, or at least un-check it by default, and check used indicators.

Thanks


TT
#8

Tamas

08.09.2022 10:14

Type changed from Feature to Bug

Status changed from Refused to New

I have discussed it with Marc and you have right :) 

We will remove ATR from Trades on Chart. It doesn't make sense to display it if it not used in the strategy.


Petr please fix it.

PS
#9

Petr Šomek

04.10.2022 14:31

Status changed from New to In progress

MF
#10

Mark Fric

06.10.2022 09:32

Status changed from In progress to Refused

correction - we'll be not removing it.


ATR is computed internally, it is used for some crosschecks and other places. This is why it is always there, even if not explicitly used in strategy rules.


To remove it we'd need to add special checking which would slow it down a little.

I don't see anything bad about having one more indicator data to show on chart, ATR is a good indicator of volatility and it can be turned off.




AA
#11

Alex

06.10.2022 10:48
So please turn it off in trades on chart by default (remove the tick in its checkbox) if it is not used inside strategy.
PS
#12

Petr Šomek

06.10.2022 14:21

Status changed from Refused to Fixed

finished - this indicator is turned off in default

Votes: +1

Drop files to upload

or

choose files

Max size: 5MB

Not allowed: exe, msi, application, reg, php, js, htaccess, htpasswd, gitignore

...
Wait please